Is Coney Island Picnic legit? On record — independent trust score 59/100, computed from public data, not paid reviews. What that rests on ↓
coneyislandpicnic.com · Fashion & Apparel · Shopify · catalog read 2026-10-30
Coney Island Picnic is a fashion & apparel store with 90 products — mostly shirt, hat and shopping totes, averaging $42. Per its own published policies, returns run 14 days and delivery is stated at up to 10 business days. The domain has been registered since 2021. 31% of the products we sampled are marked down, typically by 41%.
#1,230 of 1,685 in Fashion & Apparel · higher than 24%
Score breakdown and niche spread
Ceiling today: 85 until the owner verifies the domain
Is Coney Island Picnic legit?
Is Coney Island Picnic legit? On record — independent trust score 59/100, computed from public data, not paid reviews. Strongest signal: deep catalog: 89 distinct products on public record. Main caveat: 28 of 28 marked-down items quote a "was" price they did not sell at on any of the 30+ days we recorded their price. The catalog carries 90 products, and of the 90 we sampled 100% carry an image and 100% a real description. Its own policy page states a 14-day return window. The domain has been registered since 2021 (5 years), not a freshly-made lookalike. The score is down 7 points since we started tracking this store. Recomputed 2026-10-30 from coneyislandpicnic.com's own public feed and policy pages.
+ Strengths
- Deep catalog: 89 distinct products on public recordSource: product feed ↗
- Accessible entry price: from $12 (average $41.55)Source: product feed ↗
- Publishes refund + shipping policiesSource: store policies page ↗
- Active on 4 social platformsSource: store homepage ↗
- Runs an affiliate program (via UpPromote)Source: store homepage ↗
− Weaknesses
- 28 of 28 marked-down items quote a "was" price they did not sell at on any of the 30+ days we recorded their priceSource: price history (daily snapshots)
Its $41.55 average price is 41% below the $70.00 median for Fashion & Apparel stores in the registry. Its entry price of $19.99 sits against a $19.95–$450.00 spread between the 10th and 90th percentile of the niche. Recomputed nightly across every scored store in Fashion & Apparel.
What does Coney Island Picnic sell, and what does it cost?
Be Present Graphic Sweatpants$59.00
Together We Stand Graphic Sweatpants$59.00
Caribbean Islands Graphic Sweatpants$59.00
Doodle Friends Graphic Sweatpants$59.00
Coney Island Athletics Club Graphic Short Sleeve Tee$19.99$35.00−43%
Old Ways Cardigan$59.99$79.00−24%
Believe Varsity Jacket$119.99$169.00−29%
Born to Win Graphic Sweatshirt$64.00
Mind is a Weapon Chess Graphic Pullover Hoodie$59.00
Interpersonal Calm Graphic Pullover Hoodie$69.00
Factory Team Scallop-Hem Gym Short$59.00
Dead Jazz Trucker Hat$30.00
Death Metal Meditation Club Trucker Hat$30.00
CIP Butterfly Alpine Sherpa Bucket Hat$34.00
90% Devil Beanie$14.99$29.00−48%
Inner City Cowgirl Golfer Hat$42.00
Born to Win Beanie$17.99$32.00−44%
Your World Graphic Sweatpants$59.00
Coney Island Picnic Psychedelic Research Crew Neck Sweatshirt$59.00
CIP Clown Graphic Short Sleeve Tee$20.00$34.00−41%
Evolutionary Progress Graphic Short Sleeve Tee$39.00
x Everlast Hockey Jersey$79.00
Born Free Graphic Ringer Tee$19.99$39.00−49%
Barbed Butterfly Beanie$32.00Top-scored in Fashion & Apparel
Stores like Coney Island Picnic →
Actions
Promote this store
No program is open through StoreProfiles yet. The queue is shown to the owner if they claim this profile.
Coney Island Picnic’s site links an affiliate program run on UpPromote.
What the store hasn't confirmed yet
4 of 4 · never counted against the score · how an owner closes these
- Domain ownership — not verified by the store
- Response to the audit — no response from the store
- Affiliate terms — not published
- Public contact details — not confirmed on the storefront
What would raise this score
- +15Verify domain ownership (one meta tag, DNS record or file)profile unclaimed
- +8Show a product rating of 4.3+ across 50 or more public reviewsno rating found on the sampled product page
Own this store?
Claim the profile: update the record, answer the audit, set commission. Verifying domain control adds 15 points to this public score (59 → 74). It never changes the audit or lets anyone edit the findings.
Common questions about Coney Island Picnic
Coney Island Picnic what’s actually discounted →Coney Island Picnic return policy in full →Coney Island Picnic shipping and delivery →return windows across the registry →discounts across the registry →shipping across the registry →stores priced in USD →
- What is Coney Island Picnic's return policy?
- Coney Island Picnic accepts returns within 14 days, delivery is stated at up to 10 business days. Read from the store's own policy pages, re-read nightly. Its wording: “within 14 days of receiving your order”
- What is Coney Island Picnic's trust score, and how does it compare?
- 59/100, computed from coneyislandpicnic.com's own public data — not paid or user-submitted reviews. That is higher than 24% of the 1685 Fashion & Apparel stores we have scored. The profile is unclaimed, so 15 claim points cannot be earned and the ceiling today is 85.
- How much does Coney Island Picnic cost?
- Across the 90 products we sampled, Coney Island Picnic averages $41.55, and its entry price (10th percentile) is $19.99. That is 41% below the $70 median for Fashion & Apparel stores in the registry. 31% of that sample is marked down, median 41% off, deepest 57%.
- When was Coney Island Picnic last checked?
- catalog: 2026-10-30; domain registration: 2026-09-25. Daily snapshots on file since 2026-08-28 — 64 of the last 90 days.
What changed at Coney Island Picnic
The catalog went from 223 to 90 products between 2026-09-14 and 2026-10-30 — down 133. The average price moved from $42.80 to $41.55 between 2026-09-14 and 2026-10-30, 3% lower. Its trust score went from 66 to 59/100 under the same formula (v0.10), since 2026-09-14.
Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 — credit with a link.
StoreProfiles (2026). Coney Island Picnic: trust score 59/100 (rules v0.10). Retrieved 2026-10-30 from https://storeprofiles.com/store/coneyislandpicnic. Licensed CC BY 4.0.
Paste on coneyislandpicnic.com — the badge redraws itself after every audit, no script, no tracking.
<a href="https://storeprofiles.com/store/coneyislandpicnic" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> <img src="https://storeprofiles.com/badge/coneyislandpicnic" alt="Coney Island Picnic trust score on StoreProfiles" width="200" height="52"> </a>
Full profile, score breakdown and snapshot history — free, CORS-open, cached hourly.