Is Sugarpill legit? On record — independent trust score 62/100, computed from public data, not paid reviews. What that rests on ↓
sugarpill.com · Beauty & Skincare · Shopify · catalog read 2026-10-30
Sugarpill is a beauty & skincare store with 117 products — mostly lip color, pressed eyeshadow and false eyelashes, averaging $20. Per its own published policies, shipping is free over $50. The domain has been registered since 1999.
Also listed for a published free-shipping threshold and a domain registered 20+ years ago.
#315 of 955 in Beauty & Skincare · higher than 66%
Score breakdown and niche spread
Ceiling today: 85 until the owner verifies the domain
Is Sugarpill legit?
Is Sugarpill legit? On record — independent trust score 62/100, computed from public data, not paid reviews. Strongest signal: deep catalog: 117 distinct products on public record. Main caveat: free shipping only over $50 — about 4 median-priced items in this catalog. The catalog carries 117 products, and of the 117 we sampled 100% carry an image and 100% a real description. The domain has been registered since 1999 (27 years), not a freshly-made lookalike. The score is up 1 points since we started tracking this store. Recomputed 2026-10-30 from sugarpill.com's own public feed and policy pages.
+ Strengths
- Deep catalog: 117 distinct products on public recordSource: product feed ↗
- Accessible entry price: from $5 (average $19.83)Source: product feed ↗
- Publishes refund + shipping policiesSource: store policies page ↗
- Active on 3 social platformsSource: store homepage ↗
- Collects customer reviews (Yotpo)Source: store homepage ↗
− Weaknesses
- Free shipping only over $50 — about 4 median-priced items in this catalog“, whether you buy 1 item or 100, with free shipping for orders $50 and over (gift cards excluded”Source: store shipping policy ↗
- 17 of 17 marked-down items quote a "was" price they did not sell at on any of the 30+ days we recorded their priceSource: price history (daily snapshots)
Its $19.83 average price is 34% below the $29.99 median for Beauty & Skincare stores in the registry. Its entry price of $10 sits against a $8.99–$148.00 spread between the 10th and 90th percentile of the niche. Recomputed nightly across every scored store in Beauty & Skincare.
What does Sugarpill sell, and what does it cost?
School Daze Bundle$54.00$60.00−10%
Blackout Bundle$45.00$50.00−10%
Barbie™ Lip Gloss$8.00$20.00−60%
Trixie Mattel Oh Honey! 2 Bundle$58.00$92.00−37%
3 Capsule Collection Bundle$90.00$126.00−29%
Blacklisted Liquid Eyeliner$16.00
Trinket Liquid Lip Color$20.00
Loose Eyeshadow MEGA Bundle$60.00$168.00−64%
Trinket Trio Bundle$54.00$60.00−10%
Keepsake Liquid Lip Color$20.00
Duo Eyelash Adhesive$6.50
Empty 12-Pan Pro Palette$5.00$20.00−75%
Crystal Trinket Lip Gloss$20.00
Trixie Mattel Oh Honey! 2 Makeup Collection$38.00$52.00−27%
Trixie Mattel Oh Honey! 2 Lip Duo$24.00$40.00−40%
False Eyelash Bundle$27.00$30.00−10%
Vertigo Liquid Lip Color$20.00
Wanderlust Pressed Eyeshadow$14.00
Heatwave Pressed Eyeshadow$14.00
Nebula Pressed Eyeshadow$14.00
Frisky Lower Eyelashes$10.00
Alter Ego Lower Eyelashes$10.00
Troublemaker Lower Eyelashes$10.00
Faint False Eyelashes$10.00Top-scored in Beauty & Skincare
Stores like Sugarpill →
Actions
Promote this store
No program is open through StoreProfiles yet. The queue is shown to the owner if they claim this profile.
What the store hasn't confirmed yet
4 of 4 · never counted against the score · how an owner closes these
- Domain ownership — not verified by the store
- Response to the audit — no response from the store
- Affiliate terms — not published
- Public contact details — not confirmed on the storefront
What would raise this score
- +15Verify domain ownership (one meta tag, DNS record or file)profile unclaimed
- +8Show a product rating of 4.3+ across 50 or more public reviewsno rating found on the sampled product page
Own this store?
Claim the profile: update the record, answer the audit, set commission. Verifying domain control adds 15 points to this public score (62 → 77). It never changes the audit or lets anyone edit the findings.
Common questions about Sugarpill
Sugarpill what’s actually discounted →Sugarpill shipping and delivery →discounts across the registry →shipping across the registry →stores priced in USD →
- What is Sugarpill's return policy?
- Return postage is the buyer's to pay, outbound shipping is free over $50. Read from the store's own policy pages, re-read nightly. Its wording: “, whether you buy 1 item or 100, with free shipping for orders $50 and over (gift cards excluded”
- What is Sugarpill's trust score, and how does it compare?
- 62/100, computed from sugarpill.com's own public data — not paid or user-submitted reviews. That is higher than 66% of the 955 Beauty & Skincare stores we have scored. The profile is unclaimed, so 15 claim points cannot be earned and the ceiling today is 85.
- How much does Sugarpill cost?
- Across the 117 products we sampled, Sugarpill averages $19.83, and its entry price (10th percentile) is $10.00. That is 34% below the $29.99 median for Beauty & Skincare stores in the registry. 15% of that sample is marked down, median 14% off, deepest 75%.
- When was Sugarpill last checked?
- catalog: 2026-10-30; domain registration: 2026-09-18. Daily snapshots on file since 2026-08-02 — 90 of the last 90 days.
What changed at Sugarpill
The catalog went from 112 to 117 products between 2026-09-14 and 2026-10-30 — up 5. Its trust score went from 61 to 62/100 under the same formula (v0.10), since 2026-09-14.
Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 — credit with a link.
StoreProfiles (2026). Sugarpill: trust score 62/100 (rules v0.10). Retrieved 2026-10-30 from https://storeprofiles.com/store/sugarpill. Licensed CC BY 4.0.
Paste on sugarpill.com — the badge redraws itself after every audit, no script, no tracking.
<a href="https://storeprofiles.com/store/sugarpill" target="_blank" rel="noopener"> <img src="https://storeprofiles.com/badge/sugarpill" alt="Sugarpill trust score on StoreProfiles" width="200" height="52"> </a>
Full profile, score breakdown and snapshot history — free, CORS-open, cached hourly.