Stores like Honest Amish
12 independently audited Beauty & Skincare stores that share at least 30% of product categories with Honest Amish, ranked by similarity in trust score, pricing and catalog — computed from public data, not by who pays.
The closest audited alternatives to Honest Amish are Prequel (57/100), PUMIEY (49/100) and CrossFit Linchpin (52/100) — Beauty & Skincare stores ranked by similarity in trust, catalog and price, not by who pays.
The store
honestamish.com · BTY-2115 · Beauty & Skincare
Closest alternatives
| Store | Trust | Products | Entry | Catalog overlap | Why similar | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | Prequelprequelskin.com | 57/100 | 62 | $10 | 50% | focused 62-product range, higher trust (57 vs 47), pricier low end ($10 vs $7.77), overlapping product mix | Compare → |
| 02 | PUMIEYpumiey.net | 49/100 | 28 | $23.99 | 50% | focused 28-product range, similar trust (49 vs 47), pricier low end ($23.99 vs $7.77), overlapping product mix | Compare → |
| 03 | CrossFit Linchpincrossfitlinchpin.com | 52/100 | 102 | $5.50 | 50% | broad 102-product range, similar trust (52 vs 47), cheaper low end ($5.50 vs $7.77), overlapping product mix | Compare → |
| 04 | REFYrefybeauty.com | 39/100 | 61 | £12 | 50% | focused 61-product range, lower trust (39 vs 47), pricier low end (£12 vs $7.77), overlapping product mix | Compare → |
| 05 | Bask Suncarebasksuncare.com | 56/100 | 48 | $18 | 50% | focused 48-product range, higher trust (56 vs 47), pricier low end ($18 vs $7.77), overlapping product mix | Compare → |
| 06 | Verb Productsverbproducts.com | 58/100 | 94 | $21.60 | 50% | focused 94-product range, higher trust (58 vs 47), pricier low end ($21.60 vs $7.77), overlapping product mix | Compare → |
| 07 | verb products canadacaen.verbproducts.com | 54/100 | 100 | CA$25 | 50% | broad 100-product range, higher trust (54 vs 47), pricier low end (CA$25 vs $7.77), overlapping product mix | Compare → |
| 08 | Arctic Bayarctic-bay.ca | 56/100 | 42 | CA$270 | 50% | focused 42-product range, higher trust (56 vs 47), pricier low end (CA$270 vs $7.77), overlapping product mix | Compare → |
| 09 | Beauty Coliseumbeautycoliseum.com | 65/100 | 329 | $5.99 | 50% | broad 329-product range, higher trust (65 vs 47), cheaper low end ($5.99 vs $7.77), overlapping product mix | Compare → |
| 10 | Andeana Hatsandeanahats.com | 60/100 | 98 | $40 | 50% | focused 98-product range, higher trust (60 vs 47), pricier low end ($40 vs $7.77), overlapping product mix | Compare → |
| 11 | Jeffree Star Cosmeticsjeffreestarcosmetics.com | 59/100 | 255 | $20 | 50% | broad 255-product range, higher trust (59 vs 47), pricier low end ($20 vs $7.77), overlapping product mix | Compare → |
| 12 | Ashley Lee Cosmeticsashleyleecosmetics.com | 65/100 | 204 | $3.99 | 50% | broad 204-product range, higher trust (65 vs 47), cheaper low end ($3.99 vs $7.77), overlapping product mix | Compare → |
Column definitions: dataset card. Source: public product feeds, 2026-09-15.
Straight answers
- What are the best alternatives to Honest Amish?
- The closest audited alternatives to Honest Amish are Prequel (57/100), PUMIEY (49/100) and CrossFit Linchpin (52/100) — Beauty & Skincare stores ranked by similarity in trust, catalog and price, not by who pays. The closest match, Prequel, shares 50% of its product categories with Honest Amish; across the top three the overlap runs 50%, 50%, 50%. Similarity blends that overlap with trust score, low-end price and catalog size. Nothing here is a paid placement.
- Is Honest Amish better than the alternatives listed here?
- Honest Amish scores 47/100 on the independent trust score. The closest alternatives score 57, 49, 52. The score measures what a store publishes — catalogue depth, image and description coverage, honest pricing, published policies — and says nothing about customer service, which we deliberately do not collect.
- How are these beauty & skincare alternatives chosen?
- The 12 shown are the closest of all 809 other beauty & skincare stores on record, and each shares at least 30% of product categories with Honest Amish; they are ranked by similarity rather than by payout or popularity. The inputs are each store's own public product feed, and the list is recomputed every 24 hours.
How these are picked
Only Beauty & Skincare stores that share at least 30% of product categories with Honest Amish, counted against the smaller of the two catalogs, qualify. They are ranked by trust score (35%), catalog overlap (30%), low-end price (20%) and catalog size (15%). Each factor is defined on how we score. No store can buy a place on this list.
Computed by StoreProfiles under rules v0.10, from the store’s own public data and recomputed nightly. No page here is hand-edited and no store can pay to change one. How the score is computed · Who pays for this