Skip to content
Scores are never sold.How it works
StoreProfiles

The State of Shopify Supplements & Nutrition — September 2026

229 Supplements & Nutrition stores on record, 229 of them live and audited, listing at least 30,778 products between them. Behind the live list sit 81 domains checked and retired — dead stores don't haunt this registry. Catalog sizes come from walking every page of each store's public feed; the price figures and catalog depth below come from the products we store for each store, which for larger catalogs is a sample rather than every item. Refreshed hourly.

229 live storesat least 30,778 products listed81 domains retiredmedian trust 53/100

00Top picks in Supplements & Nutritioneach one leads a different measurable axis

Highest audited trust scoreBrainmd77/100trust score, computed from the store’s own public dataDeepest catalogNaturesante2,000+ productsnumber of products in the store’s public feed; 3 stores share this figure, trust score breaks the tieLongest return windowWild Foods90-day returnsdays stated on the store’s own refund page, quoted on its profile; 6 stores share this figure, trust score breaks the tieLowest low-end priceCure Hydration$2.50the tenth percentile of the catalog — where the range actually startsFastest stated deliveryNeuro2 business daysthe slowest case the store commits to in writing, not its fastest option; 5 stores share this figure, trust score breaks the tie

How these are picked. Each line is the top of one measured column — trust score, catalog size, stated return window, low-end price, stated delivery — taken from the same nightly data behind every profile. Ties go to the higher trust score, no store appears twice, nothing is weighted by hand, and no placement here can be bought.

01Score distributiontrust scores across the live catalog

Trust score distribution for Supplements & Nutrition: 83 stores score <50, 87 stores score 50–59, 50 stores score 60–69, 9 stores score 70–79, 0 stores score 80+83<508750–595060–69970–79080+

The median Supplements & Nutrition store scores 53/100, landing in the 50–59 bucket — also the largest, holding 87 of 229 stores.

02PricingUSD prices only · items under $2 excluded

Median price$35
p10–p90 range$15–$91
Excluded2,630 items priced in other currencies sit outside these percentiles.
Most accessible at 75+ trust

Lowest low-end price — the 10th percentile of a store’s prices — among stores scoring 75 or higher.

Naturemade76/100low end $10.79Brainmd77/100low end $13.99O Positiv75/100low end $26.99
Premium tier

Highest average price per store across the USD catalog.

Pendulum37/100avg $246Quicksilverscientific57/100avg $170Soylent58/100avg $163

03Catalog depthdistinct product titles per store

Catalog depth distribution for Supplements & Nutrition: 36 stores carry <25 distinct products, 54 stores carry 25–49 distinct products, 74 stores carry 50–99 distinct products, 65 stores carry 100+ distinct products36<255425–497450–9965100+

The median store has 58 distinct titles among the products we store for it. Depth is scored on distinct titles — a catalog padded with duplicate listings earns no extra points.

04Top 10 by trustprecise score breaks the ties

Top 10 Supplements & Nutrition stores by trust score
№StoreTrustProductsLow-end priceClaimed
01Brainmdbrainmd.com77/100204$13.99—
02Naturemadenaturemade.com76/100195$10.79—
03O Positivopositiv.com75/100361$26.99—
04Micro Ingredientsmicroingredients.com73/100480$19.99—
05Bulk Supplementsbulksupplements.com73/100805$20.86—
06Applied Nutritionappliednutrition.uk72/100251£4.95—
07Naturesantenaturesante.ca72/1002,000+CA$3.63—
081st Phorm1stphorm.com71/100508$22.50—
09Maryruth Organicsmaryruthorganics.com70/100271$18.95—
10Double Wood Supplementsdoublewoodsupplements.com69/100204$19.95—

05What the audits sayrule hits across 229 audits

  • 9 of 229 audits flag duplicated listings — catalogs of 20+ items where under 70% of listings are distinct products, so depth is scored on distinct products only.
  • 16 stores earn the “accessible vs the niche” pro: their cheapest product is priced more than 25% below the niche’s median cheapest product, compared in the same currency.
  • 17 stores carry the “premium vs niche median” con — an average price more than 2× the niche’s median store average, in the same currency.
  • 32 audits flag thin product descriptions — catalogs where fewer than 70% of products carry meaningful copy.

Every audit line cites its public source — read the methodology.

06 — Use the data

Browse the 229 audited Supplements & Nutrition stores

Every store in this report has a full profile: score breakdown, catalog, and partner queue. Own one of them? Claiming is free and adds a public right of reply.

Browse Supplements & Nutrition →Claim your store