Stores like Olly
12 independently audited Supplements & Nutrition stores comparable to Olly by trust score, pricing and catalog — computed from public data. Ranked by similarity, not by who pays.
The closest audited alternatives to Olly are Freshcap (58/100), Transparent Labs (60/100) and Strong Coffee Company (58/100) — Supplements & Nutrition stores ranked by catalog similarity, not by who pays.
The store
olly.com · SUP-1227 · Supplements & Nutrition
Closest alternatives
| Store | Trust | Products | Entry | Why similar | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | Freshcapfreshcap.com | 58/100 | 18 | $9.99 | focused 18-product range, similar entry ($9.99) | Compare → |
| 02 | Transparent Labstransparentlabs.com | 60/100 | 69 | $10 | focused 69-product range, similar trust (60 vs 58), similar entry ($10) | Compare → |
| 03 | Strong Coffee Companystrongcoffeecompany.com | 58/100 | 46 | $9 | focused 46-product range, similar entry ($9) | Compare → |
| 04 | Host Defensehostdefense.com | 57/100 | 63 | $10.95 | focused 63-product range, similar trust (57 vs 58), similar entry ($10.95) | Compare → |
| 05 | Ehplabsehplabs.com | 56/100 | 47 | $9.95 | focused 47-product range, similar trust (56 vs 58), similar entry ($9.95) | Compare → |
| 06 | Artahartah.co | 56/100 | 55 | £10 | focused 55-product range, similar trust (56 vs 58), similar entry (£10) | Compare → |
| 07 | Vital Proteinsvitalproteins.com | 55/100 | 37 | $9.99 | focused 37-product range, similar trust (55 vs 58), similar entry ($9.99) | Compare → |
| 08 | Ultima Replenisherultimareplenisher.com | 58/100 | 25 | $7.99 | focused 25-product range, cheaper entry ($7.99 vs $9.99) | Compare → |
| 09 | Wthnwthn.com | 57/100 | 69 | $9 | focused 69-product range, similar trust (57 vs 58), similar entry ($9) | Compare → |
| 10 | Jade Leaf Matchajadeleafmatcha.com | 55/100 | 31 | $9.99 | focused 31-product range, similar trust (55 vs 58), similar entry ($9.99) | Compare → |
| 11 | OLIPOPdrinkolipop.com | 55/100 | 50 | $9.50 | focused 50-product range, similar trust (55 vs 58), similar entry ($9.50) | Compare → |
| 12 | Terra Originterraorigin.com | 56/100 | 42 | $10.99 | focused 42-product range, similar trust (56 vs 58), similar entry ($10.99) | Compare → |
Trust is the independent score (higher is better). Entry price is the cheapest item ≥ $2 — positioning, not a ranking. Products is the full catalog where measured, else the sample on record. Source: public product feeds, 2026-07-29.
Straight answers
- What are the best alternatives to Olly?
- The closest audited alternatives to Olly are Freshcap (58/100), Transparent Labs (60/100) and Strong Coffee Company (58/100) — Supplements & Nutrition stores ranked by catalog similarity, not by who pays. Similarity is computed from four public signals — how close the trust scores are, how far the product catalogues overlap by category, how close the entry prices sit, and how comparable the catalogue sizes are. Nothing on this page is a paid placement.
- Is Olly better than the alternatives listed here?
- Olly scores 58/100 on the independent trust score. The closest alternatives score 58, 60, 58. The score measures what a store publishes — catalogue depth, image and description coverage, honest pricing, published policies — and says nothing about customer service, which we deliberately do not collect.
- How are these supplements & nutrition alternatives chosen?
- From every store on record in the same niche, ranked by similarity to Olly rather than by payout, popularity or any commercial arrangement. The weights are published, the inputs are each store's own public product feed, and the list is recomputed every 24 hours.
How these are picked
Every Supplements & Nutrition store on record is scored against Olly on four public-data factors, then ranked by the weighted blend below. No store can buy a place on this list.
- 35%Trust score. Closeness of the independent trust score — the smaller the gap, the higher the match.
- 30%Product overlap. Shared product-type vocabulary from each catalog's own feed — how much the merchandise actually overlaps.
- 20%Entry price. Ratio of the cheapest item ≥ $2 in each store — similar price positioning scores higher.
- 15%Catalog size. Closeness of catalog depth by tier, so a 200-item shop pairs with peers, not 2,000-SKU giants.