{"code":"HMK-1022","code_is_stable":false,"id":"smithey","slug":"smithey","name":"Smithey Ironware","domain":"smithey.com","niche":"home-kitchen","claimed":false,"description":null,"profile":"https://storeprofiles.com/store/smithey","badge":"https://storeprofiles.com/badge/smithey","trust_score":57,"verdict":"Is Smithey Ironware legit? On record — independent trust score 57/100, computed from public data, not paid reviews. Strongest signal: established catalog of 64 distinct products. Main caveat: premium pricing vs the niche median $91.92 — average here is $240.76.","niche_percentile":39,"score_breakdown":{"catalog_depth":{"got":5,"max":25},"images":{"got":15,"max":15},"descriptions":{"got":12,"max":12},"pricing_data":{"got":8,"max":8},"on_record":{"got":5,"max":5},"claimed":{"got":0,"max":15},"verified_signals":{"got":12,"max":20}},"catalog":{"product_count":66,"catalog_truncated":false,"products_sampled":66,"min_price":"15.00","avg_price":"240.76","currency":"USD"},"review":{"model":"rules-v0.12","version":0,"pros":[{"point":"Established catalog of 64 distinct products","source":"product feed"},{"point":"Accessible entry price: from $15 (average $240.76)","source":"product feed"},{"point":"Publishes refund + shipping policies","source":"store policies page"},{"point":"Active on 3 social platforms","source":"store homepage"},{"point":"Live customer support (Re:amaze)","source":"store homepage"}],"cons":[{"point":"Premium pricing vs the niche median $91.92 — average here is $240.76","source":"product feed"}],"who_for":null,"created_at":"2026-09-15T15:34:02.790Z"},"owner_response":null,"top_products":[{"title":"The Carbon Steel Lid","price":"95.00","currency":"USD","image_url":"https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0269/8225/2637/files/2026_Product_Carbon-Steel-Lid_9.jpg?v=1782917971","url":"https://smithey.com/products/the-carbon-steel-lid","product_type":null},{"title":"Cleaning & Care Kit","price":"40.00","currency":"USD","image_url":"https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0269/8225/2637/files/acc-1_10_d9d304ac-4af3-47e7-af3f-808f94c5eb8e.png?v=1750953705","url":"https://smithey.com/products/cleaningandcarekit","product_type":"Accessory"},{"title":"The Campfire Set","price":"650.00","currency":"USD","image_url":"https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0269/8225/2637/files/04282026-SmitheyeCommApril-STUDIO16065-preview.webp?v=1779991631","url":"https://smithey.com/products/the-campfire-set","product_type":null},{"title":"No. 11 American Anniversary Skillet","price":"210.00","currency":"USD","image_url":"https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0269/8225/2637/files/Smithey-250-11-Final-096-preview.webp?v=1778699252","url":"https://smithey.com/products/no-11-american-anniversary-skillet","product_type":"Cast Iron"},{"title":"The Main Course Set","price":"1000.00","currency":"USD","image_url":"https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0269/8225/2637/files/03052026-SmitheyMAReComm-STUDIO5645.jpg?v=1776889507","url":"https://smithey.com/products/the-main-course-set","product_type":null},{"title":"1 Qt Saucepan","price":"175.00","currency":"USD","image_url":"https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0269/8225/2637/files/03052026_-_Smithey_MAR_eComm_-_STUDIO5683-preview.webp?v=1774448951","url":"https://smithey.com/products/1-qt-saucepan","product_type":"Cast Iron"},{"title":"Send Your Smithey Back to us for Engraving","price":"40.00","currency":"USD","image_url":"https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0269/8225/2637/products/Send-Your-Smithey-Back-to-us-for-Engraving.jpg?v=1657568464","url":"https://smithey.com/products/send-your-smithey-back-to-us-for-engraving-copy","product_type":null},{"title":"The Essentials Set","price":"420.00","currency":"USD","image_url":"https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0269/8225/2637/files/Smithey_eComm_0632.jpg?v=1695318961","url":"https://smithey.com/products/the-essentials-set","product_type":null},{"title":"The Fish Skillet","price":"300.00","currency":"USD","image_url":"https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0269/8225/2637/files/08112025-SmitheyFishSkillet-STUDIO14925.jpg?v=1755614807","url":"https://smithey.com/products/fish-skillet","product_type":"Carbon Steel"},{"title":"Engraving Line 2","price":"20.00","currency":"USD","image_url":"https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0269/8225/2637/files/Your_Text_Here.png?v=1779978225","url":"https://smithey.com/products/engraving-line-2","product_type":"Service"},{"title":"The Ultimate Set","price":"3295.00","currency":"USD","image_url":"https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0269/8225/2637/files/2026_Product_The-Ultimate-Set-Square.jpg?v=1786731117","url":"https://smithey.com/products/the-ultimate-25-piece-set","product_type":null},{"title":"Double Burner Griddle","price":"295.00","currency":"USD","image_url":"https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0269/8225/2637/files/2026_Product_Double-Burner-Griddle_6-Square.jpg?v=1787672307","url":"https://smithey.com/products/double-burner-griddle","product_type":"Cast Iron"}],"history":[{"day":"2026-07-19","product_count":63,"catalog_total":null,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":null,"rules_version":null},{"day":"2026-07-20","product_count":63,"catalog_total":null,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":80,"rules_version":"v0.5"},{"day":"2026-07-21","product_count":63,"catalog_total":null,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":82,"rules_version":"v0.6"},{"day":"2026-07-22","product_count":63,"catalog_total":null,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":82,"rules_version":"v0.6"},{"day":"2026-07-23","product_count":63,"catalog_total":null,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":82,"rules_version":"v0.6"},{"day":"2026-07-24","product_count":64,"catalog_total":null,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":83,"rules_version":"v0.6"},{"day":"2026-07-25","product_count":64,"catalog_total":null,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.7"},{"day":"2026-07-26","product_count":64,"catalog_total":null,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.7"},{"day":"2026-07-27","product_count":64,"catalog_total":null,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-07-28","product_count":64,"catalog_total":null,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-07-29","product_count":64,"catalog_total":null,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-07-30","product_count":64,"catalog_total":null,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-07-31","product_count":64,"catalog_total":null,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-01","product_count":64,"catalog_total":null,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-02","product_count":64,"catalog_total":null,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-03","product_count":64,"catalog_total":null,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-04","product_count":64,"catalog_total":null,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-05","product_count":87,"catalog_total":87,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":55,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-06","product_count":87,"catalog_total":87,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":55,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-07","product_count":87,"catalog_total":87,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":55,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-08","product_count":64,"catalog_total":64,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-09","product_count":64,"catalog_total":64,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-10","product_count":64,"catalog_total":64,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-11","product_count":64,"catalog_total":64,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-12","product_count":64,"catalog_total":64,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-13","product_count":64,"catalog_total":64,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-14","product_count":64,"catalog_total":64,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-15","product_count":64,"catalog_total":64,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-16","product_count":64,"catalog_total":64,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-17","product_count":64,"catalog_total":64,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-18","product_count":67,"catalog_total":67,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-19","product_count":67,"catalog_total":67,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-20","product_count":67,"catalog_total":67,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-21","product_count":67,"catalog_total":67,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-22","product_count":67,"catalog_total":67,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-23","product_count":67,"catalog_total":67,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-24","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-25","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-26","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-27","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-28","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-29","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-30","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-08-31","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-09-01","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-09-02","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-09-03","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-09-04","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-09-05","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-09-06","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-09-07","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-09-08","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-09-09","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.8"},{"day":"2026-09-10","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.9"},{"day":"2026-09-11","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":53,"rules_version":"v0.9"},{"day":"2026-09-12","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.9"},{"day":"2026-09-13","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.9"},{"day":"2026-09-14","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":null,"min_price":null,"trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.10"},{"day":"2026-09-15","product_count":66,"catalog_total":66,"avg_price":"240.76","min_price":"15.00","trust_score":57,"rules_version":"v0.10"}],"partner_program":{"active":false},"data_updated":"2026-09-15T05:06:48.977Z"}